Home    Subscribe    Contact    Login

Do movies based on books, ruin those books for you?

by dgrwriting (follow)
Photographer and writer.
Movie Adaptions (1)      Based on Books (1)     
When a movie is based on a book, it often doesnít turn out exactly how readers see it in their brains. Does the movie ever spoil the book for you? If so, which book? Is there a movie that enhanced the book for you?



Harry Potter Books by J.K. Rowling


Categories
#Movie Adaptions
#Based on Books
I like this Question - 5
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
No. Usually I've read the book first. I read Red after seeing the movie and am in AWE that they came up with that movie after reading such a hardcore tiny comic!!
The movie doesn't usually ruin the book for me. If I don't like the film, I may be annoyed with what they did to the plot and characters, but that just makes the book all the more special to me because nothing can outdo it. If I don't like the film, then I just dismiss it, and stick to the book.

Some films have enhanced my enjoyment of books, however, as they sometimes make it easier to visualise. One example is 'The Road'.
For me, movies normally don't ruin the books they are based on but the opposite can happen quite easily. If important events are changed or left out, I tend to get miffed. The things that normally get me is often if a book is really long, events will be glossed over or omitted. This makes the movie hard to follow or feel disjointed.
I think the books are usually better, and yes, if you read the book first, I think it spoils the movie and probably vice versa also.
by Finy
More Articles by dgrwriting
view all articles by dgrwriting
Articles by dgrwriting on Other Hubs
My Google Plus Profile
ID: 19657
Trending Articles
Categories
 
Copyright 2012-2017 On Topic Media PTY LTD. ABN 18113479226. mobile version