Home    Subscribe    Contact    Login

Do you prefer computer animation or hand drawn?

by Bryony Harrison (follow)
Poems on the Page: tinyurl.com/pgyyx76
Animation (18)      Animation Comp (3)      Cartoons (2)      Technology (1)     
In the early days Disney and other animation companies drew all their animated films by hand. One of the best examples of the stunning work achieved this way is Bambi. Now, however, almost all animated films are made with computer drawings. Which do you prefer and why? If it is 2D animation can you even tell the difference?


#Animation Comp
I like this Question - 5
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
I'm absolutely in love with hand-drawn animation (on paper or on computer, so I don't thing the distinction made in the OP is appropriate). The style and talent traditional animation showcases is out of control.

That said, I have never seen a 2D production that compared to the acting nuance of a contemporary 3D animated feature. 2D is frankly disadvantaged when it comes to nuance; in 3D it's possible to chisel down the layers and create a subtle, affective acting move, while in 2D it's so much harder to iterate, because each change takes up to 100 times as much work, depending on the length of the scene. There has been some phenomenal acting in traditional production, but I feel like even at it's best, only one or two characters could ever really shine, because there aren't enough Glen Keanes to go around.

Also, I just love animation. I don't care what technique. I love cutout, rotoscope, mocap, the old Ralph Bakshi xerox style, the works.
I find hand written animation is just SO clever -I would love to have this talent and they are so very talented.

However, with computers nowadays and the things they can do, I think I probably prefer computer animation as they have done some fabulous things like this.
by Finy
Like Finy, I am astounded at the sheer talent of those who made the amazing hand drawn films in the early days. Like I stated above, I think Bambi is a masterpiece. I do prefer hand drawn animation when it is done as well as that, but I can't ignore what computer animation has allowed us to see. For example, that scene in the ballroom in Beauty and the Beast would not have been possible by hand.
Like most here, I prefer hand drawn. I enjoy computer animation too but here is a cookie-cutter feel to it that you just don't get with hand drawn animation.
More Articles by Bryony Harrison
view all articles by Bryony Harrison
Articles by Bryony Harrison on Other Hubs
My Google Plus Profile
ID: 23206
Trending Articles
Copyright 2012-2021 OatLabs ABN 18113479226. mobile version