I saw the 1961 version first and absolutely loved it. I then saw the Lohan version when I was 11, and like it, but not as much. By the time I was 13, however, I had seen that one several more times, and grown to like it more than the original. Now, however, I find that as an adult, I get bored by Lohan's version, but still love the original, so that is my favourite again.